June 1, 2004
Gr 5-8-These brief books present a remarkable amount of information and provide readers with a clear understanding of complicated issues. Aircraft describes the airplane's coming-of-age during the war-from being totally discounted as a fighting machine to the Aces, who became national heroes. The second volume focuses on eight well-known battles that took place before America entered the conflict in 1917, describing the senseless slaughter that was typical of World War I. Short biographical sketches of important figures appear throughout. Events discusses the conditions and circumstances in each of the participating countries. In all three titles, the unbiased texts are illustrated with mostly black-and-white and sepia photos varying from postage-stamp size to full page. Some full-color paintings are included, and maps are used when appropriate. Although its format is more crowded and a little less inviting, Donald Sommerville's World War I (Raintree, 1999) is more in-depth and covers almost everything contained in these three volumes. Kathlyn and Martin Gay's World War I (21st Century, 1997) uses a personal-interview approach for much of its content and has less specific information about events. Hamilton's offerings make excellent introductions to the specific topics.-Eldon Younce, Harper Elementary School, KS
Copyright 2004 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
July 1, 2004
These straightforward narratives focus on different aspects of World War I. Brief sidebars highlight military and political leaders; reproductions, maps, and well-chosen black-and-white photos extend the text. "Aircraft", "Trench", and "Weapons" offer detailed portraits of their subjects. The other three volumes tend to oversimplify events. Timeline. Glos., ind.
(Copyright 2004 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)